I recently finished the entire book series, and am working through the last couple tie in novellas. Really really enjoyed the books, and the show actually stayed pretty damn faithful to the source material (even incorporating the side novella material as well). I want to go back and watch the series again.

6/22/2024 7:41:58 AM

6/22/2024 8:13:21 AM

kinda disappointed in how they ended the series... seems like they were building up to something, we never really got the story behind the rings or who sent protomatter and why.

6/26/2024 1:54:36 AM

The books basically explain it.

6/29/2024 9:32:44 AM

I just finished all 6 seasons of this show. Pretty good.

11/2/2025 8:22:09 PM

But I feel like AI is the protomolecule of today's reality. Seemingly capable of a lot, but potentially dangerous when subjected to unrestrained and unchecked f'n around by corporate and state actors.

11/3/2025 10:17:15 PM

Just watched the pilot, definitely will catch a few more episodes.

11/5/2025 8:11:26 PM

You are in for a treat, it’s so damn good. I want to do a rewatch, but fuck Prime for having commercials now

11/5/2025 10:16:35 PM

^^It's very well done, and since I have recently watched it, I am open to discussion / commentary, as I've been unsuccessful getting anyone else to watch it. I don't push it, as that would be tacky and annoying, but I just mention it as a recent good watch for general fans of the genre and those looking for a new series to binge. I think my brother-in-law will watch it eventually.

11/6/2025 10:20:55 AM

Up to episode 8. Luckily no commercials/ads for me

Its pretty good. Sometimes the chest thumping by the 5, soon to be 4 remaining survivors is a little over dramatic. I wish there had been a little more back story? I mean it just jumps straight into the middle of the story it seems. Maybe let audience know more about OPA, and just generally how the universe works. Writers are good at putting characters at what seems a dead end and keeping it going. These ppl like never shower either!!! The one iranian(kinda make her seem indian on show) lady must have used to smoke cigs or something, her voice is so annoying! The detective character and that whole arc seems off right now. Like totally unrelated to the other part of the story of the ppl on the rosinante. I guess only thing that ties them together is that Mao broad, and the OPA "stealth" weapon? Idk right now the detective thing just seems strange, but I can see them tying it in. I kinda dislike the look of his character anyway with that gay ass hat, etc. And who didn't see the police chief turning on him?? Feel bad about Holden losing his poontang in the pilot, i feel like him and nagata are gonna hook up. Its funny how quick ppl change, like those Mars police like interogating them, then all the sudden homeboy like dies saving them. Fred Johnson dude thinks hes got them then all the sudden Holden makes a deal and they go on their way. Few other times where its all the sudden some 180 turn or "convenience" in the story that kinda doesn't make sense but keeps things moving

Hoping to get to at least episode 3 or 4 of season 2 by the end of today

11/6/2025 11:23:54 AM

Well i was an episode away from detective dude being brought together with the rocinante peeps. They changed intro on episode 9, long as fuck too at like 1hr30min for finale

Up to episode 1 of season 2 now, see my holden/nagata bwning guess didn't take long

Season 1 actually lowest rotten tomatoes, 2-5 are like 100%, 6 is 96, 1 is like 78

Rotten tomatoes kinda sucking now anyways, hear metacritic is better

[Edited on November 6, 2025 at 6:53 PM. Reason : Add another observation]

11/6/2025 6:51:34 PM

You legit bingeing, son!

But I kind of would watch a season at a time over weekends as able.

Stick with it. It will tie together.

The character played by the Iranian lady is supposed to be Indian. She definitely chain smoked or still does. It was annoying to me also, but the character grew on my over time. Her husband is played by the guy who played Pakistani restauranteur Babu Bhatt on Seinfeld, but he's actually British Israeli from Indian and Iraqi parents.

There are some strong characters in this show.

11/6/2025 7:45:34 PM

Is there always some shit going on? Or at the least is there a few episodes here and there were things are like calm? Or is it always doom and gloom save the universe from evil ppl with bioweapons etc

11/6/2025 9:10:20 PM

There’s usually some shit going on. Season 4 is a smaller more focused storyline

11/6/2025 9:56:40 PM

It's just a seriously long slog of one thing after another!

I feel like syfy spent like half their budget on this one show lol. Not that there's anything wrong with that

Seems like a prequel and/or sequel type series would be easy if there was an appetite for it, but doubt this show has enough groundswell of support to get it made



[Edited on November 6, 2025 at 10:18 PM. Reason : Kinda want to read first 2 pages of this thread. Hope no big spoilers]

[Edited on November 6, 2025 at 10:23 PM. Reason : Lol dtownral really hated that ladys voice too]

11/6/2025 10:11:41 PM

The reason I watched or even was aware of this show was because people said that the way For All Mankind storylines had been developing, it could conceivably be viewed as an unofficial prequel to The Expanse. But they aren't actually related. I saw that in the YouTube comments somewhere.

11/6/2025 11:26:14 PM

Hey is miller and naomi gonna fuck cause i noticed she shed a tear for him...

I typically don't care about spoilers, so feel free to answer that one(all 2 of you, plus marko lol)

Will google that mankind show you mentioned as an unofficial prequel

[Edited on November 7, 2025 at 12:00 AM. Reason : Episode 5 of season 2 is REALLY good imo. Miller kissing Julie the blue ghost/spirit thing]

11/6/2025 11:37:49 PM

Quote :

"Hey is miller and naomi gonna fuck"

No. He ded now. Sort of.

Quote :

"Will google that mankind show you mentioned as an unofficial prequel"

It's on Apple TV. It's also pretty good, and still under active development. They are about to come to out with Season 5 of a planned 7 season story arc. It's an alternate history sci-fi show.

11/7/2025 12:10:10 AM

Is he gonna turn all translucent blue like Julie?

Lol just got to where they told amos and indian dude they were sleeping together. I like amos like yeah shes a sister to me...i'd do her if she let me lololol

11/7/2025 12:13:45 AM

"Glad we had this talk."

Amos is good. Well cast. He's got some other really good lines in the series.

11/7/2025 12:21:47 AM

Intergalactic poontang

Found perfect example of unnecessary antagonism. Indian navigator dude to Amos..."you don't know what you are talking about, as usual"- there is shit like that all the time in this show thats kind of annoying

[Edited on November 7, 2025 at 12:37 AM. Reason : Add another observation]

11/7/2025 12:26:30 AM

No, they're all from the same galaxy.

11/7/2025 12:41:29 AM

Same galaxy poon is ok too

11/7/2025 1:28:15 AM

Are you gonna watch more tonight?

11/7/2025 8:27:56 PM

S3 episode 8 right now

Errinwright gives me a gavin newsom vibe

Amos has got to be the best character on this show. Then Alex. I like documentary lady was wanting to bwn amos but he said no. Then cameraman i guess thought he might be homo since he declined the lady, so asked Amos if he had a chance lol

So far it almost seems like season 3 is like 2 halves. Like tied up stuff in episode 6, episode 7 with intro of the guy with big scar on face, naomi not on rocinante, etc seem tonally different so far

11/8/2025 5:06:23 AM

Yeah. Amos is the best. He is that guy.

11/8/2025 7:09:23 AM

LOLOL!

11/8/2025 9:21:50 AM

The recurrent use of Mormons as a plot device in this series was interesting.

11/8/2025 2:24:01 PM

Yeah i kinda don't get that. Feel like i've seen them twice, and heard them mentioned a few times, but don't really get the significance. I thought i hated miller but now that he is coming back as holden seemingly loses his mind, i kinda missed him.

Is that speechwriter and the black lady she speaks to a few times together? Looks like the kid was mixed. I can't tell if just a nanny taking care of the kid or if she is speechwriters significant other

^^^lol so saw Amos saying that when he talked botanist out of killing the doc

Fred Johnson is such a vanilla name lol.

Saw s6 only 6 episodes. Kind of a bummer. Was reading about how syfy declined to pick it up and ppl like flew planes with banners over bezos house or something like that, and 2 weeks after syfy made announcement, bezos himself saved series

Thinking back to pilot, seems weird they got jonathan banks to play such a small insignificant part

11/8/2025 2:56:18 PM

Yeah, gay preacher lady was kinda forced.

11/8/2025 3:02:52 PM

Sometimes i feel like some plot things take too long to complete and the payoff kinda weak

Like errinwright finally getting in trouble, julie mao search, botanist searching for daughter

Still at episode 8 but not feeling this documentary crap with creepy cameraman fucking with ship, not feeling arc with guy who clearly wants to be captain on whatever ship naomi is on now(maybe if an episode or 2 but feel this is gonna go on rest of season at least), not feeling arc of lady that keeps crying and sweating a lot that put explosive and killed the guy who played the janitor in the movie the breakfast club

11/8/2025 3:14:46 PM

It might be a bit much to ask of the writers for every viewer to love every individual story line. Keep a holistic focus.

11/8/2025 4:11:16 PM

Hows this for productive? Watching an episode while i walk on treadmill and sauna

11/8/2025 5:27:27 PM

Treadmill and TV inside a sauna?!

11/8/2025 6:12:54 PM

Well first treadmill and then sauna.

Glad naomi gonna rejoin rocinante soon. Getting good again after episodes 7 and 8.

I need to look up that one OPA captain thats kinda being undermined by her first mate that used to be a captain, she got some weird accent. Why did that guy that used to be a captain show up anyways? Don't recall them ever saying why, he just kinda showed up

11/8/2025 6:49:05 PM

The actress sounds NOTHING like the accent developed for her character:



She's Canadian First Nations (equivalent to Native American).

11/8/2025 7:08:27 PM

Dang thats crazy! I figured like some eastern european country or something.

Right now slow goings for me. Buffering like crazy. Might go to amazon(but don't want commercials) or just use cellular, but thats like a gb per hour last i checked. Stuck with 50mb down att at my apt, no other options

[Edited on November 8, 2025 at 9:12 PM. Reason : One more ep in s3 left, then to see if amazon is noticeably different than syfy]

[Edited on November 8, 2025 at 9:15 PM. Reason : Internet sucking!]

11/8/2025 9:10:50 PM

So whats the deal with the proto-molecule? Like it was some bad ass blue creature that fed off radiation. It was contagious turning others blue and badass. Then miller and julie mao(who was infected and blue) were on eres and i guess julie had it hit venus instead of earth. And then all the sudden the proto-molecule ceased being some bad ass blue alien thing into a ship that then formed a ring near saturn. And now they did something to open up a bunch of "wormholes" into other systems?

I guess my question is, how did proto-molecule go from alien creature thing, to some giant wormhole ring thing?

[Edited on November 8, 2025 at 11:28 PM. Reason : And they never really did revisit the small amount of blue goo that was left in the rocinante after patching up that panel]

11/8/2025 11:27:45 PM

Patience!

11/9/2025 7:47:53 AM

Sucks about babu bhatt. New husband isn't even close to similar lol

Nice to see amos finally get some poontang

I feel like amazon put up location names a lot mote often than syfy

11/9/2025 7:30:20 PM

Yeah, I was not a fan of that recasting, but apparently Brian George was unavailable.

11/9/2025 7:35:53 PM

So is it possible for you and money jones and anyone else for that matter to rank the seasons?

I guess I'd say 2, 1, 3 for me so far. Unsure if money jones saying season 4 is less stuff happening means he liked it more or less

Bobbie brother drug thing is seeming pretty dumb already.

11/9/2025 7:47:35 PM

I don't have clear enough memory delineations about what happened in which season to rank them as you are requesting.

11/9/2025 8:10:27 PM